The Court’s decision has important implications for the French Constitution and the interplay between economic growth and the environment.
By Paul A. Davies, Fabrice Fages, and Michael D. Green
On 31 January 2020, the French Constitutional Court (Conseil Constitutionnel) took a decision that aimed to balance the protection of the environment and human health with the freedom of enterprise, both of which are protected under the French Constitution. (Decision n° 2019-823 QPC)
The matter was brought before the Court through an application for a priority preliminary ruling on the issue of constitutionality (question prioritaire de constitutionnalité). This procedure was introduced in 2008, and confers the right for any person involved in legal proceedings before a court to argue that a statutory provision invoked in the context of litigation infringes rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution.

On 6 March 2019, seven Chinese regulatory agencies issued the Green Industry Guidance Catalogue (the Catalogue) listing “green industries” that are eligible for funding with green bonds. The seven agencies include the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC), Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, Ministry of Natural Resources, Ministry of Ecology and Environment (MEE), Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development, The People’s Bank of China, and the National Energy Board.
At the 2014 National People’s Congress, Chinese Premier Li Keqiang’s rhetoric adopting an “iron fist” approach in a “war against pollution” represented a stunning volte-face from China’s relaxed environmental oversight and prioritization of economic growth over the preceding four decades.
MPs in France have adopted an amendment to include a new paragraph in Article 1 of the French Constitution. The amendment reads:
Recent comments from senior communist party leaders indicate that the Chinese government intends to establish a new Ministry of Energy to streamline and consolidate authority for energy-related issues. The responsibility for these issues is currently dispersed among a variety of other ministries. The new ministry will be responsible for managing sectors including electric power generation, oil and natural gas in a bid to improve the workings of government and policymaking in relation to energy. However, the full extent of the new ministry’s authority remains unclear, including whether it will have oversight of China’s state-owned oil companies.